This was my first time coming to this restaurant and I was pleased! I had a Chicago deep dish pizza and buffalo wings. The pizza was really good, but I would've like a little more sauce on the pizza. The only flavor wings they have are buffalo and its kind of a dry rub, but they were good. The ranch dressing is good, the pizza was good, the service was good. I ordered takeout and the lady I spoke to was had great service over the phone and in person!
Tony Pigeon
-
April 20, 2025
I usually go for pizza, but the spaghetti was calling my name once I walked through the door. You can smell the goodness once you go in. Our whole table got pasta, and each meal was a home run. I got the spaghetti "Papa Capi" style, and let me tell ya, I have finally met my match. That was the best dang plate of spaghetti I've ever had!!! It was more like 2 plates, I could barely get half of it down! I'll be back next time to check out the deep dish pizza! (and get another Papa Capi to go)
Felix Mirabal
-
April 25, 2025
37th St Pizza 🍕 is fabulous! Great taste, properly seasoned 😜..... The fresh hoagie is definitely delicious! The Staff is courteous and friendly.My friends, also try out the Taco Pizza, you will receive plenty of sauce! Visit them soon.....
Samantha Long
-
October 19, 2024
The flavor of the pizza was good, however we ordered a thin crust and a Chicago Style Deep dish, as you can see by the pictures there really was no difference in the crusts. Coming from Chicago I was a little disappointed as it was not Chicago style. The first picture is their thin crust and the second picture is their Chicago style deep dish. The service was great.
Kevin Gaskill
-
June 02, 2025
Pizza was not my favorite but was Ok. Wife’s Stromboli was very good though. Problem was the server got the size wrong, they fixed it but we were already behind schedule and this made it more so. Also the dining areas are long and narrow so the servers and patrons are bumping into you or your table as they pass. I had to walk through the middle of a birthday twice on my trip to the bathroom. I might have been able to bypass it by going through the bar area but if so, it wasn’t clearly marked.
Our Address
2402 Neuse Blvd, New Bern, NC 28562, USA
Ads Title
Claim Listing: Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
This was my first time coming to this restaurant and I was pleased! I had a Chicago deep dish pizza and buffalo wings. The pizza was really good, but I would've like a little more sauce on the pizza. The only flavor wings they have are buffalo and its kind of a dry rub, but they were good. The ranch dressing is good, the pizza was good, the service was good. I ordered takeout and the lady I spoke to was had great service over the phone and in person!
I usually go for pizza, but the spaghetti was calling my name once I walked through the door. You can smell the goodness once you go in. Our whole table got pasta, and each meal was a home run. I got the spaghetti "Papa Capi" style, and let me tell ya, I have finally met my match. That was the best dang plate of spaghetti I've ever had!!! It was more like 2 plates, I could barely get half of it down! I'll be back next time to check out the deep dish pizza! (and get another Papa Capi to go)
37th St Pizza 🍕 is fabulous! Great taste, properly seasoned 😜..... The fresh hoagie is definitely delicious! The Staff is courteous and friendly.My friends, also try out the Taco Pizza, you will receive plenty of sauce! Visit them soon.....
The flavor of the pizza was good, however we ordered a thin crust and a Chicago Style Deep dish, as you can see by the pictures there really was no difference in the crusts. Coming from Chicago I was a little disappointed as it was not Chicago style. The first picture is their thin crust and the second picture is their Chicago style deep dish. The service was great.
Pizza was not my favorite but was Ok. Wife’s Stromboli was very good though. Problem was the server got the size wrong, they fixed it but we were already behind schedule and this made it more so. Also the dining areas are long and narrow so the servers and patrons are bumping into you or your table as they pass. I had to walk through the middle of a birthday twice on my trip to the bathroom. I might have been able to bypass it by going through the bar area but if so, it wasn’t clearly marked.